This really shouldn't be a surprise given that my uncle Humpsey had three similarly-named cousins of the same generation in school with him at the same time.
Before I get into searching for Humphrey Collinses in Caheragh, I thought I would mention this tip about searching the church records. The first name field can take a large boolean expression or a wild card - within limits.
If you want to search for John, enter: (Jn or Jno or John or Jon or Johannes or Joannes or Joannim or Johannam)
If you want to search for men named Morty, you can enter Mor*.
As far as I can tell, the first name field does not take a union of two wild card results. For example, if I want to search Hum* or Um* as a boolean expression, it doesn't work that way; however (Hum* or Ump*), with a minimum of three letters, may work.
Now the problem with Humphrey is that name - really any name - can be mistranscribed. I suspect a Morty Collins is really a Humphrey, and I also found a few occurrences of Murphy Collinses who are Humphreys.
When Skibbereen Heritage originally looked for my gg-grandfather Michael Collins, born about 1822, they were unable to locate a baptism record for a Michael son of Humphrey Collins and Johanna Barnane. And they probably searched Drimoleague & Drinagh as well. Humphrey and Johanna were married in early 1820 - though that marriage record has its problems - and the first child Catherine was born in December of that year - and that birth record has a few problems too. Then nothing until son John was born 1824.
So there is certainly a convenient slot for my gg-grandfather, whose birth year I estimated from the 1901 census. If he and his wife Ellen Driscoll were "old school" in the way they named their children, their first daughter might have been named after the paternal grandmother. That also fits, as daughter Johanna was born 1856. Ellen's mother was Margaret Loony.
Then the additional church records came online and I took a shot at searching for a baptism record for Michael and found one - born to a Humphry Collins and Ellen Sweeny in September 1822, and it looks like they were staying in Blue Hill (Knockgorm) at the time.
I went to Skibb Heritage and was told their records had that indexed as Morty. So I went on a fishing expedition and collected several handwriting samples and compared them. In the image below, the entry labeled 1822 in the left column was indexed as Morty at Skibb Heritage and Umpy on the church record site. The rest in the left column are indexed at the church record site as Humphry, Umpy, or Umphry or similar. The entries in the right-hand side are from Morty Hourihanes in Caheragh about the same time (so presumably handwritten by the same priests).
I think Morty is Umpy. And I can't dismiss this as some fluke or mistake. There is no other Michael born to a Humphry Collins. A Catherine Sweeny showed up at the wedding of Michael Collins and Ellen Driscoll in 1854. In fact, that Catherine Sweeny may have married just five days before to a Hourihane from Tooreen. Could Catherine Sweeny have been a cousin or aunt to Michael?
And then there's my DNA. I have a decent Family Finder match to somebody with Sweeny in his list of names. So far I haven't heard anything in response to my inquiries.
The online records have just opened up a whole new set of questions. There are no more records for Ellen Sweeny with this Morty/Umpy Collins. However, there is an Ellen Sweeny with a Denis Collins in Knockgorm shortly after, and they had several children.
The imagination can run wild here. I have not seen church records state whether parents are dead or alive. Could Morty/Umpy have been deceased and could Ellen Sweeny have remarried?
To get a better handle on the Humphrey Collinses running around, I decided to construct a timeline of sorts:
Where's Humphrey Collins?
|1820-Feb-15||D & D||marriage||Humphrey Collins & "Mary" Bernard(1)|
|1820-Jul-12||Caheragh||baptism||Anne Barrett||sponsor Humphry Collins|
|1820-Dec-02||Caheragh||baptism||Catherine Collins||parents Humphry Collins(2) Johanna Bernard|
|1820-Dec-17||Caheragh||baptism||Cornelius Keohane||Humphry Collins sponsor|
|1822-Sep-08||Caheragh||baptism||Michael Collins||parents Humphrey Collins(3), Ellen Sweeny|
|1824-May-18||Caheragh||baptism||John Collins||parents Humphry Collins, Johanna Barnane|
|1826-Feb-04||Caheragh||marriage||Charles Brien & Mary Collins||Humphry Collins & Mary Brien witness|
|1827-Sep-02||Caheragh||baptism||Mary Collins||parents Humphry Collins, Johanna Barnane|
|1828-Sep-20||D & D||baptism||Joan Mangan||mother Mary Collins, Humphry Collins sponsor|
|1829-Dec-13||Caheragh||baptism||Nory Collins||parents Humphry Collins, Johanna Barnane|
|1830-Mar-19||Caheragh||baptism||Pat Crimeen||Humphry Collins sponsor|
|1830-Oct-01||Caheragh||baptism||Catherine Minihane||Humphry Collins sponsor|
|1831-Aug-01||Caheragh||baptism||Humphrey Collins||parents Michael Collins & Mary Donovan|
|1831-Aug-24||Caheragh||baptism||Denis Carthy||Humphry Collins sponsor|
|1832-Jan-20||Caheragh||baptism||Bridget Bary||Umphy Collins sponsor|
|1833-Feb-19||Caheragh||marriage||John Casey & Catherine Burke||Humphry & Michael Collins witness|
|1833-Feb-19||D & D||marriage||Cornelius Hourihan & Honora Casey||Humphry Collins witness|
|1833-Aug-07||Caheragh||baptism||James Collins||parents Humphry Collins, Johanna Barnane|
|1833-Oct-24||Caheragh||baptism||Jerry Coakley||Humphry Collins sponsor|
|1835-Dec-07||Caheragh||baptism||Johanna Collins||parents Humphry Collins, Johanna Barnane|
|1836-Dec-27||Skibbereen||baptism||John Collins||parents Humphry Collins, Mary Galvin|
|1838-Sep-16||Skibbereen||baptism||Margaret Collins||parents Humphry Collins, Mary Galvin|
|1839-Feb-05||Skibb & Rath||marriage||John Collins & Margaret Donovan||Humphry Collins witness|
|1839-Mar-14||Caheragh||baptism||Pat Collins||parents Humphry Collins, Ja(o)ne Barrett(4)|
|1840-Mar-25||Caheragh||baptism||Pat Coakly||Humphrey Collins sponsor|
|1841-Jan-19||Skibbereen||baptism||Mary Collins||parents Humphry Collins, Mary Brien|
|1843-Apr-02||Skibbereen||baptism||Johanna Collins||parents Humphry Collins, Mary Brien|
|1845-Oct-23||Skibbereen||baptism||Jerry Collins||parents Humphry Collins, Mary Collins|
|1846-Jan||Caheragh||baptism||Pat Cadigan||sponsors Humphry Collins, Johanna Bernard(5)|
|1851-Mar-01||Caheragh||marriage||Catherine Collins & Denis Donovan||Humphry Collins & Honora Collins witness|
|1854-Feb-28||Caheragh||marriage||Michael Collins & Ellen Driscoll||Humphrey Collins, Catherine Sweeny witness|
|1858-Jan-23||Caheragh||marriage||John Collins & Ellen McCarthy||Humphry Collins witness|
|1858-Jan-29||Caheragh||baptism||Humphry Collins||Humphry Collins sponsor; Michael Collins & Ellen Driscoll parents|
|1858-Nov-19||Caheragh||baptism||Humphry(7) Collins||John Collins & Ellen McCarthy parents|
|1861-Aug-24||Caheragh||baptism||Humphrey(8) Collins||Denis Collins & Margaret Mahony parents|
|1862-Mar-04||Skib & Rath||marriage||James Collins & Catherine Driscoll||Humphry Collins witness|
|1863-Apr-22||Kilmacabea||baptism||Humphry Collins||son of a Jerry?|
|1873-Apr-17||Caheragh||death||Humphrey Collins, age 88||Humphrey Collins present at death (left mark)|
|1873-May-28||Caheragh||baptism||Timothy Collins||Humphry Collins sponsor|
|1875-Nov-07||D&D||baptism||Humphry Collins(6)||parents Patrick Collins,Catherine Collins|
|1879-May-14||Skibbereen||baptism||Denis Collins||Humphrey Collins, sponsor|
- 1 - Skibb Heritage was of the opinion the priest made an error and this should have been Johanna.
- 2 - Another error - father is recorded as John and baptism sponsor Humphry.
- 3 - Probably my direct ancestral line.
- 4 - There is no confusion between Barrett and Barnane. The handwriting of Barrett is clear, and there were Barretts in Lissane. However, I haven't dug up a marriage record for a Humphrey Collins and a Jane/Joan Barrett, which makes me wonder if the priest was hard of hearing or what!
- 5 - Johanna Barnane was alive as late as 1846, which means that her husband couldn't have been married to Mary Galvin or Brien at the same time - therefore there was at least one other Humphry!
- 6 - Indexed as Helen!
- 7 - Whoever indexed this entry gave up entirely on the first name and just left it blank.
- 8 - The father Denis *could* have been the son of Michael Collins and Mary Donovan of Lissane Lower. This couple had a son named Humphrey in 1831. But there is no baptism record of Denis.
I can't figure out what was going on in 1833. Humphry went to two different Casey weddings on the same day?!? In fact his calendar was so full in 1833 it makes me wonder if he had time to farm.
Caheragh records start in mid-1818; Drimoleague & Drinagh mid-1817. Now, what about Skibbereen records? There are multiple Skibbereen parish entities. According to Skibbereen Heritage, Skibbereen & Rath were one parish until 1851. What is listed as Creagh & Sullon are the baptism records of this combined parish and then Skibbereen after 1851. Baptism and marriage records of Rath post 1851 are under Rath & Islands. Skibbereen & Rath start listing marriages in 1837.
Given that Mary Galvin and Mary Brien were baptizing their children in Skibbereen and not Caheragh, this information leads me to conclude that their marriage records fall out of range, so that information is forever lost.
I am curious about the names Galvin and Mangane. There are a few Galvins here and there. Mangane is rather uncommon. I get the feeling these names could be agnomens for another name. Brien, perhaps?
Ultimately, I am going to have to view every single image to decide for myself if the transcriptions are correct and if my assumptions are correct.